Ruling Attachment Ledger / 裁定附条件账本

Ruling Attachment Ledger is a board card for already-valid rulings that are not yet cleanly usable because the ruling carries enforceable conditions.

It records the attachments that make a served order legitimate: notice, remedy, exclusion, monitor, channel limit, proof bridge, witness protection, artist boundary, public receipt, sponsor carve-out, editor checksum, or archive seal. A ruling without its attachments may still exist, but using it as a universal key creates breach pressure.

When this card appears

Offer this card from state when all are true:

entry_state:
  ruling_or_order_state: served | mandate_assigned | complied_partial | settlement_active | legality_converted | proof_burden_shifted | custody_order_live
  attachments_min: 2
  future_route_reads_attachment_state: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true

Do not offer this card because a numbered turn, arbitrary day count, chapter quota, or lens/dashboard status has been reached.

Required row shape

attachment_row:
  row_id: <stable id>
  source_ruling: <source order / event / storyline>
  source_relief_kept_true: []
  attachment_kind: notice | remedy | exclusion | monitor | channel_limit | proof_bridge | witness_protection | artist_boundary | public_receipt | sponsor_carveout | editor_checksum | archive_seal
  obligated_party: inspector | archive | sponsor | editor | public_fan | artist | witness | manager | pirate | route_asset | explicit_absence
  carrier_or_monitor: <card / character / route asset / explicit_absence>
  satisfied_by: <assignment / proof / explicit_absence>
  breach_if_absent: <breach state>
  future_route_accepts_when: []
  future_route_rejects_or_taxes_when: []

Attachment states

State	Meaning	Required consequence
attachment_unserved	The condition exists but no credible party has carried it.	Future use is blocked, taxed, or breach-armed.
attachment_served	A party has satisfied the condition with proof.	One route accepts the ruling, with a visible cost or exposure.
attachment_public_only	Public receipt exists but lawful proof is missing.	Public route can proceed; formal route needs conversion.
attachment_lawful_only	Formal seal exists but public/artist notice is absent.	Formal route can proceed; public/artist route gains distrust or refusal risk.
attachment_editor_only	Continuity patch exists without raw proof or public bridge.	Broadcast continuity route improves; archive/raw-proof route narrows.
attachment_sponsor_gated	Sponsor paid or packaged the condition.	Immediate pressure drops; future use requires sponsor gate or capture cost.
attachment_contested	Two parties claim incompatible satisfaction.	Collision, conversion, or quarantine must resolve before clean use.
attachment_breached	The ruling was used while the condition was unmet or mismatched.	Breach event mutates future availability.
attachment_recovered_with_scar	Later proof restores partial legitimacy.	Route reopens with named scar, surcharge, or channel limit.

Playable use

This card is not an inventory of clauses. Every live row must create at least one assignment question:

• who carries notice;
• who proves remedy;
• who must be excluded from use;
• who monitors the order;
• which channel accepts the copy;
• whose proof bridge is missing;
• which future route rejects a mismatched attachment.

Counter surfaces

Relevant branch deltas include:

• attachment_compliance
• attachment_breach_risk
• lawful_acceptance
• public_acceptance
• artist_boundary_respect
• archive_signature_legitimacy
• editor_checksum_legitimacy
• sponsor_gate_pressure
• inspection_heat
• public_receipt_distrust
• contract_capture
• route_asset_pressure
• future_route_acceptance
• future_recovery_cost

Non-goals

• Not a new verdict.
• Not a generic legal checklist.
• Not a fixed turn phase.
• Not a free cleanup for enforcement debt.
• Not valid if every served order can be reused without checking its attached conditions.