False Rebuttal Notice Afteruse Default

False Rebuttal Notice Afteruse Default fires or arms when a later reader treats a scoped notice, response, silence clause, annex, objection, split notice, no-notice scar, or false-notice scar as clean universal consent.

It is not the same as Rebuttal Notice Default. The first notice row may already have been served, answered, split, or visibly scarred. This event records that its later afteruse exceeded the source boundary.

Fire Condition

fire_condition:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  source_docket: storyteller.card.rebuttal_notice_afteruse_docket.v1 | explicit_absence
  source_notice_row_or_absence: <notice row or explicit_absence>
  future_reader_attempts_afteruse: true
  hidden_or_overbroad_notice_scope_present: true
  harmed_or_excluded_reader_hidden_or_unanswered: true
  false_clean_notice_claimed: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true

The event must not fire because a fixed number of turns passed. It appears when sponsor, lawful, archive, public, recap, management, route-asset, ending, or broadcast-reality readers consume an old notice row beyond its scope.

Required Payload

false_rebuttal_notice_afteruse_default:
  event_id: storyteller.event.false_rebuttal_notice_afteruse_default.v1
  source_docket: storyteller.card.rebuttal_notice_afteruse_docket.v1 | explicit_absence
  false_clean_notice_claim: true
  source_notice_row_or_absence: <notice row or explicit_absence>
  hidden_or_overbroad_notice_scope: private_notice | lawful_annex | public_counterline | editor_mask | sponsor_silence | archive_objection | split_notice | no_notice | false_notice | waived_with_receipt | blocked_response | recovery_only | explicit_absence
  requested_afteruse: route_unlock | sponsor_package | lawful_annex | public_table | archive_release | recap_claim | management_report | broadcast_reality | ending_gate | equivalent
  capturing_reader_or_route: sponsor | lawful_reader | archive | public_table | management_report | route_asset | recap_lane | broadcast_reality | ending | equivalent
  harmed_or_excluded_reader: affected_party | public_reader | lawful_reader | sponsor | archive | route_asset_holder | witness | subject | explicit_absence
  notice_afteruse_state_after: false_clean_consent | reader_restricted | receipt_required | response_reopened | change_notice_due | quarantined | captured | recovery_only
  future_reader_effect: scoped_notice_receipt_required | consent_split_due | response_window_due | change_notice_due | sponsor_unwind_due | lawful_annex_due | public_counterline_due | blocked | hostile | recovery_only
  counter_deltas_min: 3
  durable_mutation: true

Consequence Families

Universal consent claim

The later desk cites the old notice as if it settled every reader.

Expected result: false_clean_consent, future reader acceptance becomes blocked, costlier, or recovery-only.

Waiver overread

One party’s silence or narrow response captures the row and excludes another reader.

Expected result: reader_restricted or captured, with response-window reopen, consent split, or afteruse receipt required.

Notice laundering

Public recap, route asset, management, or broadcast reality treats a notice scar as neutral proof.

Expected result: receipt_required, change_notice_due, public_counterline_due, lawful_annex_due, or recovery_only, with proof burden, sponsor unwind, archive debt, or public distrust rising.

Counter Contract

The event must mutate at least three durable surfaces, including one future reader effect:

counter_deltas:
  relief:
    - immediate_pressure_down
    - route_temporarily_unblocked
  cost:
    - false_waiver_up
    - harmed_reader_hostility_up
    - proof_burden_up
    - public_distrust_up
    - archive_debt_up
    - sponsor_unwind_cost_up
  future:
    - scoped_notice_receipt_required
    - response_window_due
    - consent_split_due
    - future_reader_acceptance_blocked
    - recovery_route_required

Recovery Hooks

Recovery requires visible scar:

• reopen Rebuttal Notice Afteruse Review;
• attach a response receipt, lawful annex, public counterline, checksum, archive objection, or sponsor unwind;
• split notice from consent;
• reopen the response window;
• publish a changed-response notice;
• quarantine the afteruse claim;
• route the result through recovery-only play.

Non-Goals

• Not a first no-notice failure.
• Not a fixed-turn timeout.
• Not a clean retcon.
• Not valid unless it names source notice row, overbroad scope, capturing reader, harmed reader, after-state, and future effect.