Clean Testimony Reuse Default / 洁净证词复用默认

Clean Testimony Reuse Default fires or arms when a later route uses an old testimony row as clean proof even though 证词翻供账本 shows a changed witness state, missing proof boundary, or harmed reader.

This event is the failure mode for 证词可靠性复听. It does not say the testimony was always false. It says management reused it without proving why the new reader can still rely on it.

Trigger contract

trigger_required:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  source_proof_id: <accepted proof row>
  accepted_state_before: accepted | accepted_with_scar | public_only | lawful_only | sponsor_only | caption_only | split_required | protected | quarantined | equivalent
  recantation_row_present_or_required: true
  witness_state_changed_or_absent: true
  new_statement_state_any:
    - narrowed
    - corrected
    - retracted
    - contradicted
    - coerced_silence
    - unavailable
    - hostile_counterstatement
    - explicit_absence
  future_reader_or_route_attempts_clean_reuse: true
  rehearing_missing_or_defaulted: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
  no_raw_testimony_count_trigger: true
  no_dashboard_or_lens_health_trigger: true

The event must not fire from fixed turn count, fixed day/week, raw share/testimony count, relationship score, dashboard state, or lens health.

Payload

default_payload:
  event: storyteller.event.clean_testimony_reuse_default.v1
  recantation_id_or_absence: <row or explicit_absence>
  source_proof_id: <proof row>
  source_surface: operator_witness_conclave | caption_witness_custody | access_caption_reliance | recap_syndication | callback_carrier_collision | protected_witness_payroll | equivalent
  witness_id_or_absence: <witness or explicit_absence>
  witness_state_before_or_absence: <state or explicit_absence>
  new_statement_state_or_absence: <state or explicit_absence>
  reliance_reader: <reader>
  harmed_or_omitted_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
  false_clean_claim: testimony_still_clean | caption_context_still_clean | operator_chain_still_clean | witness_silence_is_consent | old_reader_acceptance_serves_new_reader | equivalent
  default_narrator: sponsor | management_table | archive | lawful_reader | public_table | route_claimant | broadcast_reality | blackout_system | equivalent
  target_state_after: false_clean_reuse | hostile_reader | proof_laundered | contradiction_pending | route_blocked | recovery_only | equivalent
  future_reader_or_route_effect: blocked | costlier | hostile | correction_required | proof_rehearing_required | recovery_only | equivalent

Required mutations

At least three durable surfaces must change:

• false_clean_reuse
• testimony_reliability
• source_ambiguity
• harmed_reader_hostility
• public_receipt_distrust
• access_caption_pressure
• sponsor_stop_loss_pressure
• lawful_annex_debt
• archive_debt
• witness_safety_debt
• route_asset_pressure
• broadcast_reality_drift
• future_route_cost
• recovery_only_pressure

Outcome families

Default family	Immediate relief	Durable cost	Future effect
Sponsor clean reuse	commercial route proceeds	public/lawful harmed reader becomes hostile	sponsor_only, correction_required
Caption clean reuse	access package proceeds	caption context debt and class pressure rise	caption_witness_required, recovery_only if ignored
Archive clean reuse	lawful chain appears stable	source ambiguity and archive debt harden	proof_rehearing_required
Public clean reuse	public explanation circulates	witness contradiction becomes broadcast reality drift	contradiction_pending, costlier
Route asset clean reuse	route unlocks quickly	route asset is poisoned by proof laundering	blocked, hostile, recovery_only

Recovery

Recovery is allowed only through visible scar:

• late 证词可靠性复听;
• public correction;
• lawful annex;
• substituted proof;
• protected recantation statement;
• quarantine with route delay;
• sacrifice of a route asset or proof object.

Recovery cannot erase the default; it converts false-clean reuse into a named scar that later readers must consume.

Non-goals

• Not generic bad luck.
• Not witness death pressure.
• Not a morality event.
• Not an appeal reset.
• Not valid unless old testimony was reused as clean despite a visible or required recantation boundary.