Metric Appeal Retaliation Default / 指标申诉报复默认

Metric Appeal Retaliation Default is the event that fires or arms when a captured management metric is challenged without enough proof, channel, handler protection, or future-reader binding.

It is not a punishment for appealing. It records which claimant weaponizes the appeal gap: board, sponsor, inspector, editor, public claimant, crew table, route-asset claimant, or blackout system. The result must change future play, not only reputation.

Trigger contract

Trigger or arm this event only from state pressure:

event: storyteller.event.metric_appeal_retaliation_default.v1
trigger:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure_default
  captured_metric_report_present: true
  hidden_debt_present: true
  appeal_attempted_or_due: true
  future_reader_reads_metric_or_hidden_debt: true
  appeal_record_missing_or_underfilled: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true

Valid sources include 指标捕获默认, a false-clean management report, sponsor greenwash, schedule greenwash, liability recode, quote double count, route asset false clean, or a management-compression docket that has already been read by a later route.

The event must not fire from a fixed numbered turn, day interval, chapter quota, content-count goal, or lens-health state.

Required event record

metric_appeal_retaliation_default:
  event: storyteller.event.metric_appeal_retaliation_default.v1
  source_capture_event: storyteller.event.metric_capture_default.v1 | equivalent
  captured_report_id: <stable captured metric report id>
  captured_by: board | sponsor | schedule_desk | liability_table | crew_utilization_table | quote_table | route_asset_claimant | public_absence | equivalent
  captured_metric: slot_salvaged | liability_capped | sponsor_confidence_preserved | audience_churn_suppressed | crew_utilization_improved | quote_clearance_reused | route_asset_recovered | public_harm_contained | equivalent
  hidden_debt: <debt_counter_or_state>
  appeal_gap:
    proof_anchor: present | absent
    appeal_channel: present | absent
    handler: present | absent
    future_reader: present | absent
    retaliation_shield: present | absent
  retaliation_author: board | sponsor | inspector | editor | fan_public | crew_table | route_asset_claimant | blackout_system | equivalent
  default_state_after: appeal_discredited | sponsor_retaliation | lawful_reversal | public_backfire | crew_leak | route_asset_recapture | false_clean_hardened | recovery_only | equivalent
  future_route_effect: blocked | costlier | sponsor_only | lawful_appeal_required | public_table_required | correction_slot_required | split_required | recovery_only | producer_license_review | equivalent
  counter_deltas: {}

The event is invalid if it changes only mood, money, or generic reputation.

Retaliation families

Sponsor retaliation

A sponsor treats the appeal as bad faith and converts the captured metric into a contract weapon.

Expected mutations:

• sponsor_stop_loss_pressure or contract_capture rises;
• public_receipt_distrust or future_claim_cost rises;
• future route becomes sponsor-only, costlier, or public-table-required.

Lawful reversal

An inspector or liability table treats the underfilled appeal as proof that the original report should stand.

Expected mutations:

• inspection_heat, bureau_favor_debt, or producer_license_pressure rises;
• the hidden debt becomes lawful-only or hearing-required;
• future correction requires a stronger proof anchor.

Public backfire

A fan-public, witness, or claimant row receives an appeal without credible carrier protection.

Expected mutations:

• public_receipt_distrust, witness_exposure, or fan_oxygen_resentment rises;
• public legitimacy becomes costlier rather than cleaner;
• future public table or contrition route is narrowed.

Crew or route-asset recapture

A crew table, quote table, or route-asset claimant uses the appeal gap to retake the object or person the report falsely counted clean.

Expected mutations:

• route_asset_integrity or quote_integrity worsens;
• crew_refusal_risk, carrier_price_integrity, or future_recovery_cost rises;
• future route becomes split-required, recapture, or recovery-only.

False-clean hardened

The appeal record is hidden, underfilled, bought without release, or filed without future reader, so the captured metric becomes harder to reopen.

Expected mutations:

• false_clean_metric or captured_metric_report hardens;
• one later appeal, correction, public table, lawful conversion, or route-asset recovery becomes blocked or more expensive;
• at least one counter records the hidden debt becoming more costly.

Recovery hook

Retaliation does not have to be terminal. A later recovery route may reopen the report only by adding stronger proof, accepting a public scar, sacrificing a sponsor bridge, publishing a lawful correction, repricing the quote, protecting the crew/route asset, or putting the producer license under review.

Non-goals

• Not a generic backlash event.
• Not a fixed appeal phase.
• Not a punishment for success.
• Not a free reset to pre-default state.
• Not valid unless captured report, hidden debt, appeal gap, retaliation author, future route effect, and counter deltas are visible.