Metric Capture Appeal / 指标捕获申诉机制

Metric Capture Appeal is the management-RPG mechanism for reopening a false-clean metric after 经营压缩台机制 has failed or defaulted.

The existing management-compression layer asks whether a costly success can be counted cleanly. This mechanism fills the next gap: once the board, sponsor, schedule desk, liability table, crew table, quote table, or route-asset claimant has already captured the report, what playable cost lets the producer challenge it without pretending the failure never happened?

Mechanism promise

When 指标捕获默认 or an equivalent false-clean report has been read by a later route, the game must expose an appeal surface with:

• a stable captured report id;
• the metric that was counted;
• the hidden debt that made the count false-clean;
• an appeal claimant;
• proof, channel, handler, and retaliation-shield slots or explicit absence;
• a future route, license, slot, public statement, lawful use, quote, crew lane, or route asset that will read the appeal result.

An appeal can improve truth, legality, quote integrity, route-asset integrity, or public legitimacy. It must also create cost: sponsor retaliation, inspection heat, correction-slot pressure, crew exposure, route quarantine, producer-license review, or recovery-only routing.

State-triggered entry

Open or update this mechanism when all are true:

entry_state:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  captured_metric_report_present: true
  hidden_debt_present: true
  future_reader_reads_metric_or_hidden_debt: true
  appeal_claimant_or_producer_license_pressure_present: true
  proof_channel_handler_or_explicit_absence_representable: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true

The mechanism fails design review if it opens from a fixed numbered turn, day interval, chapter quota, raw content count, lens-health state, or generic management review phase.

Core object model

Object	Meaning	Required observable field
metric_capture_appeal_docket	visible record of a false-clean report being challenged	captured report id, captured metric, hidden debt, claimant, channel, future reader
captured_report	the report that management, sponsor, schedule, liability, quote, crew, or route-asset table already filed	captured_by, captured_metric, hidden_debt, default state before appeal
appeal_claimant	actor or surface allowed to challenge the metric	producer, comptroller, public receipt, lawful reader, sponsor confessor, crew witness, quote carrier, route asset holder
appeal_assignment	proof, channel, handler, retaliation shield, and future reader selected by the player	explicit values or explicit absence
appeal_result	new state of report and future reader after hearing	correction, lawful appeal, confession, scar publication, reprice, quarantine, split, or retaliation default
retaliation_default	what happens when the appeal is hidden or underfilled	retaliation author, appeal gap, future route effect

Appeal modes

Public table correction

Public correction names the hidden debt and attaches it to the next reader. It improves public legibility but raises exposure, sponsor pressure, and correction-slot pressure.

Lawful appeal

Legal or inspector appeal challenges liability, custody, quote, or route-asset use. It improves admissibility or metric integrity but raises inspection heat, bureau debt, release delay, and lawful-only routing.

Sponsor confession or contract sacrifice

Sponsor side letter, confession, or release narrows the false-clean report. It may lower false-clean risk but arms sponsor retaliation, contract capture, and discoverability cost.

Crew scar publication

Crew, handler, witness, quote carrier, or route asset scar becomes visible. It improves truth and route-asset integrity but raises crew refusal, exposure, management pressure, or recovery cost.

Quote detachment or reprice

A double-counted quote, price, clearance, or returned object is detached from the captured metric. It improves quote integrity while raising budget, schedule, and future clearance cost.

Route asset quarantine

A falsely clean person/object/copy is protected by making it temporarily unusable. It improves integrity while narrowing future route access until recovery.

Split metric

One metric remains usable while the hidden debt is attached to a second reader. The result is acceptable only to scoped readers, never universal cleanliness.

Suppress or no answer

An underfilled or hidden appeal arms 指标申诉报复默认.

Branch contract

Every branch must change at least three surfaces:

branch_contract:
  relief_delta_min: 1
  cost_delta_min: 1
  future_reader_or_license_delta_min: 1
  captured_report_state_changes: true
  hidden_debt_visible_or_costed: true

Valid future effects include:

• public_table_required;
• lawful_appeal_required;
• accepted_with_public_scar;
• accepted_with_release_clause;
• reprice_required;
• quarantined;
• split_required;
• producer_license_review;
• sponsor_unwind_required;
• correction_slot_required;
• recovery_only;
• blocked;
• costlier.

Integration rules

• With Management Compression Desk, this mechanism is downstream of a captured or false-clean report. It does not re-run the original review.
• With Production Triage Desk, an appeal must consume a real lane, handler, or explicit absence.
• With Public Contrition Ledger, public correction must keep apology, public receipt, or exposed scar as cost.
• With Correction Slot Auction, an appeal can compete for scarce correction attention rather than receiving a free slot.
• With Broadcast Legality Conversion, lawful appeal can narrow a route to lawful-only until heard.
• With Producer License and Pressure, failed or retaliated appeals can become license pressure rather than abstract reputation.
• With Route Assets and Custody, route-asset quarantine or recapture must change availability, integrity, or recovery route.

Counter and durable-state contract

Primary values:

• captured_metric_report
• false_clean_metric
• selected_metric_integrity
• hidden_debt_legibility
• management_pressure
• producer_license_pressure
• public_receipt_legitimacy
• public_receipt_distrust
• sponsor_stop_loss_pressure
• contract_capture
• inspection_heat
• bureau_favor_debt
• correction_slot_pressure
• quote_integrity
• carrier_price_integrity
• crew_refusal_risk
• route_asset_integrity
• route_asset_exposure
• future_claim_cost
• future_recovery_cost

Replay evidence contract

mechanic: storyteller.mechanic.metric_capture_appeal.v1
session_id: lens-metric-capture-appeal-v1-<timestamp>
seed: <deterministic-seed>
entry_state:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  captured_metric_report_present: true
  hidden_debt_present: true
  future_reader_reads_metric_or_hidden_debt: true
  appeal_claimant_or_producer_license_pressure_present: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
source_capture:
  source_capture_event: storyteller.event.metric_capture_default.v1
  captured_report_id: <id>
  captured_by: <claimant>
  captured_metric: <metric>
  hidden_debt: <state>
docket:
  card: storyteller.card.metric_capture_appeal_docket.v1
assignment:
  rite: storyteller.rite.metric_capture_appeal_hearing.v1
  appeal_mode: <mode>
  appeal_claimant: <claimant>
  proof_anchor_or_absence: <proof_or_absence>
  appeal_channel_or_absence: <channel_or_absence>
  handler_or_absence: <handler_or_absence>
  retaliation_shield_or_absence: <shield_or_absence>
  future_reader: <reader>
result:
  appeal_state_after: <state>
  captured_report_state_after: <state>
  hidden_debt_state_after: <state>
  event_seen_or_armed: storyteller.event.metric_appeal_retaliation_default.v1 | none
  future_route_effect: <effect>
  counter_deltas: {}
assertions:
  - entry_is_state_triggered
  - captured_report_and_hidden_debt_visible
  - claimant_proof_channel_handler_and_future_reader_visible
  - branches_diverge_by_report_state_cost_and_reader
  - success_has_relief_cost_and_future_gate
  - suppression_or_underfill_arms_retaliation_default
  - no_fixed_turn_trigger

Non-goals

• Not a generic appeal system.
• Not governance or dashboard reporting.
• Not a fixed review phase.
• Not a replacement for management compression, public contrition, correction slots, or legal conversion.
• Not valid if a false-clean metric can be erased without a named debt, cost, future reader, and retaliation/default path.