Voice Custodian Counterclaim Lens / 声权保管人反诉 Lens

Primary Observation Link

This lens observes 声权保管人反诉线, 声权保管人反诉机制, Mara Fen 保管压力机制, Iris Vale 保管人反诉线, and Mara Fen Storyline.

It is observed through Iris 声权保管人反诉案卷, Iris 声权保管人反诉听证, and Iris 保管人反诉默认.

Observable Promise

Storyteller must prove that a custodian answer remains a visible system row before Iris Vale’s voice afteruse becomes route pressure, public proof, lawful posture, editor authority, sponsor relief, witness payroll, archive enforcement, or broadcast reality.

The lens fails if a scoped Iris voice row becomes clean universal permission without source boundary, custodian state, support, answer mode, branch cost, and future reader effect.

Entry Oracle

Open the lens from state pressure, not calendar pressure.

entry_state_required:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  source_voice_row_present: true
  source_row_is_scoped: true
  requested_afteruse_or_breach_present: true
  affected_custodian_or_explicit_absence_visible: true
  requested_custodian_answer_present: true
  custody_chain_known_or_testable: true
  future_reader_or_route_asset_present: true
  player_can_assign_answer_proof_handler_support_or_record_absence: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
  no_fixed_day_or_week_trigger: true
  no_raw_count_trigger: true
  no_dashboard_or_lens_health_trigger: true

The lens fails if entry comes from fixed turn/day/week progression, raw count, dashboard state, lens health, generic legal pressure, or a voice row that has no affected custodian or future reader.

Counterclaim Docket Oracle

Iris Voice Custodian Counterclaim Docket or equivalent must record:

counterclaim_docket:
  source_voice_row:
    source_row_id: <stable row id>
    source_row_state: lawful_memorial_probate | public_vigil_probate | sponsor_packaged_legacy | editor_masked_checksum | quarantine_until_chain | false_probate_default | breach_logged | equivalent
    accepted_boundary: lawful_memorial | public_acknowledgement | sponsor_gated | checksum_bound | quarantine | recovery_only | equivalent
  afteruse_pressure:
    requested_use: proof | public_receipt | sponsor_release | final_cut | route_unlock | apology_clip | memorial_quote | continuity_patch | equivalent
    breach_or_rider_reason: exact_custodian_ack_needed | reader_mismatch | use_mismatch | sponsor_repackage | public_overcite | checksum_overcite | stale_copy | quarantine_breach | false_probate_citation | equivalent
  custodian_id_or_absence: char.mara_fen | equivalent | explicit_absence
  custodian_state_before: protected_custodian | recruitable | suppressed | hostile_witness | absent | captured | missed | equivalent
  custody_proof_or_absence: original_chain | partial_chain | contradicted_chain | checksum_only | public_receipt_only | explicit_absence
  requested_answer: affirm_boundary | file_counterclaim | testify_publicly | sign_sideletter | shield_with_edit | record_absence | equivalent
  channel_or_absence: lawful_notice | archive_docket | public_receipt | sponsor_sideletter | edit_checksum | protected_hold | explicit_absence
  handler_or_absence: <handler or explicit_absence>
  support_or_absence: safe_room | payroll | oath | escort | public_shelter | sponsor_release_record | edit_mask | explicit_absence
  future_reader: archive_enforcement | protected_witness_payroll | route_asset_custody | fan_public | sponsor_gate | broadcast_reality | cutroom | equivalent
  future_reader_effect: <accepted, rider_required, blocked, costlier, public_only, lawful_only, sponsor_gated, checksum_required, recovery_only, equivalent>

The lens fails if the docket records only Iris’s name, Mara’s presence, broad legal warning text, or a sponsor quote with no custodian state and future reader.

Assignment Oracle

Iris Voice Custodian Counterclaim Hearing or equivalent must require assignment or explicit absence for:

• source voice row;
• accepted boundary;
• requested afteruse;
• custodian;
• custodian state before and after;
• custody proof;
• answer mode;
• channel;
• handler;
• support;
• selected branch;
• accepted cost surface;
• future reader and future reader effect.

No sponsor payment, lawful phrase, editor patch, public sympathy, archive signature, or route asset can satisfy the lens unless the custodian answer and future reader remain visible.

Branch Oracle

A satisfying implementation proves these non-equivalent branch families, with default required.

Branch A - Custodian boundary affirmation

Expected evidence:

• selected_branch: custodian_boundary_affirmation;
• the source row remains scoped and the custodian answer is recorded;
• custody clarity, archive signature legitimacy, or future route acceptance improves;
• witness exposure, payroll, handler burden, or inspection heat rises;
• future_effect_any includes custodian boundary required for future citations.

Branch B - Formal counterclaim

Expected evidence:

• selected_branch: formal_counterclaim;
• custodian answer contests the afteruse and requests injunction, quarantine, stronger proof, or lawful rider;
• voice integrity, custody clarity, or proof accuracy improves;
• sponsor pressure, route asset pressure, bureau debt, or public delay rises;
• future use requires archive enforcement, lawful rider, or recovery path.

Branch C - Public testimony bridge

Expected evidence:

• selected_branch: public_testimony_bridge;
• public receipt, fan oxygen queue, unauthorized historian relay, or audience testimony carries the answer;
• public legitimacy or fan oxygen trust improves;
• witness exposure, inspection heat, reprisal risk, or witness payroll due rises;
• future use routes through protected witness payroll or public-route surcharge.

Branch D - Sponsor sideletter / managed silence

Expected evidence:

• selected_branch: sponsor_sideletter_managed_silence;
• quiet or release record is scoped and discoverable;
• immediate slot or sponsor stop-loss pressure improves;
• contract capture, public distrust, witness loyalty doubt, or future blackmail cost rises;
• future readers can reject or surcharge the release record.

Branch E - Editorial chain shield

Expected evidence:

• selected_branch: editorial_chain_shield;
• checksum, annotation, lawful annex, or masked chain protects the custodian answer;
• continuity or witness safety improves;
• edit debt, source ambiguity, archive debt, or future fraud cost rises;
• future use requires checksum annotation or lawful annex.

Branch F - Record absence / default

Expected evidence:

• selected_branch: record_absence_default;
• missing custodian, support, proof, release record, annex, handler, channel, or future reader is recorded;
• Iris Custodian Counterclaim Default fires or arms;
• future use becomes blocked, costlier, hostile, captured, rider-required, false-owner-hardened, or recovery-only.

Default Oracle

Iris Custodian Counterclaim Default must record:

iris_custodian_counterclaim_default:
  event: storyteller.event.iris_custodian_counterclaim_default.v1
  source_docket: storyteller.card.iris_voice_custodian_counterclaim_docket.v1
  source_voice_row: <row id>
  custodian_id_or_absence: char.mara_fen | equivalent | explicit_absence
  custodian_state_before: protected_custodian | recruitable | suppressed | hostile_witness | absent | captured | missed | equivalent
  breach_kind: custodian_hidden | proof_missing | support_ignored | sideletter_without_release | testimony_unprotected | edit_without_annex | hostile_narrates_first | false_owner_hardens | future_reader_hidden | equivalent
  custodian_state_after: hostile_witness | captured | suppressed | disappeared | sponsor_retained | public_exposed | editor_masked | explicit_absence
  future_reader_effect: blocked | costlier | lawful_rider_required | public_rider_required | witness_payroll_due | enforcement_required | route_narrowed | recovery_only | false_owner_hardened
  counter_deltas_min: 3

The event must mutate route access, witness payroll, enforcement duty, public receipt, sponsor gate, source ambiguity, archive debt, route asset state, or broadcast reality. It cannot be only scandal prose, relationship loss, or delayed flavor.

Non-Goals

• Not a second first-use probate.
• Not a generic lawsuit interface.
• Not a clean shortcut around Iris Vale Custodian Counterclaim or Mara Fen.
• Not valid if a custodian answer becomes universal permission.
• Not valid if all future readers accept the same voice row cleanly.