Precedent Caption Hearing / 先例题名听证

Precedent Caption Hearing is the management rite for deciding how a previous case enters institutional memory.

It is not a second appeal of the original case. The source branch remains true. The hearing asks whether a later desk may cite that branch as a rule for a different reader, asset, route, or inspection context.

Assignment contract

assignment_required:
  rite: storyteller.rite.precedent_caption_hearing.v1
  docket: storyteller.card.precedent_drift_docket.v1
  source_case_id: <stable id or explicit_absence>
  source_surface: oxygen_clawback_foreclosure | sponsor_afteruse_citation | continuity_afteruse_contempt | enforcement_mandate_exhaustion | ruling_reader_collision | management_compression | equivalent
  original_branch: <branch>
  original_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
  protected_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
  harmed_or_excluded_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
  source_cost_kept_true: <cost or scar>
  source_future_effect_kept_true: <future effect>
  claiming_institution: sponsor_desk | inspection_desk | archive_desk | management_desk | editor_desk | lawful_desk | fan_delegate | route_asset_holder | pirate_relay | equivalent
  claimed_rule: <rule text>
  target_case: <new route or case>
  analogy_basis: same_reader | same_asset | same_sponsor | same_signature | same_continuity_version | same_refund_shape | same_mandate_dimension | same_public_receipt | weak_similarity | equivalent
  desired_new_reader: <reader>
  excluded_reader_or_absence: <reader or explicit_absence>
  selected_posture: annotate_precedent | narrow_scope | split_readers | counter_precedent | quarantine_memory | publish_errata | accept_capture | refuse_default
  handler_or_absence: producer | shen_luo | yu_lan | han_yanshuang | baiya | inspector | sponsor_counsel | archive_clerk | fan_delegate | explicit_absence | equivalent
  proof_bridge_or_absence: docket_caption | public_footnote | archive_cross_index | reader_split_note | inspection_errata | counter_digest | quarantine_stamp | explicit_absence
  accepted_cost_surface: <cost or explicit_absence>
  future_route_effect: <effect>
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true

Branch menu

Annotate precedent

The old case may be cited, but only with its source scar and reader limitation attached.

selected_posture: annotate_precedent
relief_any:
  - institutional_memory_legible
  - false_universal_rule_blocked
cost_any:
  - public_receipt_distrust_up
  - inspection_heat_up
  - handler_burden_up
future_effect_any:
  - citation_requires_caption
  - accepted_with_scar

Narrow scope

The old case applies only to matching reader, asset, signature, continuity version, or mandate dimension.

selected_posture: narrow_scope
relief_any:
  - target_route_can_use_limited_rule
  - weak_similarity_blocked
cost_any:
  - future_conversion_cost_up
  - sponsor_or_management_pressure_up
future_effect_any:
  - narrow_precedent_only
  - analogy_check_required

Split readers

Different readers inherit different captions from the same source case.

selected_posture: split_readers
relief_any:
  - one_reader_route_unblocked
  - excluded_reader_recovery_hook_preserved
cost_any:
  - source_ambiguity_up
  - route_copies_diverge
future_effect_any:
  - split_precedent_required
  - universal_acceptance_blocked

Counter precedent

A contrary source case is attached to block institutional capture.

selected_posture: counter_precedent
relief_any:
  - captured_rule_contested
  - harmed_reader_visible
cost_any:
  - appeal_pressure_up
  - bureau_favor_debt_up
future_effect_any:
  - contested_precedent
  - future_hearing_required

Quarantine memory

The case remains real but cannot be cited until a bridge or errata exists.

selected_posture: quarantine_memory
relief_any:
  - false_rule_spread_blocked
  - source_case_preserved
cost_any:
  - route_delay_up
  - archive_debt_up
future_effect_any:
  - quarantine_until_bridge
  - recovery_only_for_target_case

Publish errata

The institution admits that earlier memory was miscaptioned.

selected_posture: publish_errata
relief_any:
  - public_memory_trust_up
  - inspection_or_archive_rule_corrected
cost_any:
  - institutional_embarrassment_up
  - sponsor_stop_loss_pressure_up
future_effect_any:
  - errata_required_for_reuse
  - public_only_until_lawful_bridge

Accept capture

The claimant’s rule is allowed, but capture is recorded and other readers become costlier.

selected_posture: accept_capture
relief_any:
  - claiming_institution_pressure_down
  - schedule_or_stop_loss_pressure_down
cost_any:
  - precedent_capture_up
  - excluded_reader_hostility_up
future_effect_any:
  - captured_precedent
  - captured_reader_gate_required

Refuse/default

No credible caption is set. The loudest institution narrates the rule.

selected_posture: refuse_default
emits_or_arms: storyteller.event.false_precedent_default.v1
future_effect_any:
  - false_precedent
  - hostile_reader
  - recovery_only
  - route_blocked

Future handoff

The hearing must mutate at least one future route, route asset, public receipt, sponsor package, archive proof, inspection report, legality conversion, or management metric. If future offers remain identical, this rite has not created gameplay.