Attachment Monitor Substitution Receipt

Attachment Monitor Substitution Receipt begins after Ruling Attachment Compliance has made a ruling usable by assigning a monitor, carrier, checksum, public witness, archive signer, or equivalent watch surface.

The current mesh proves that a ruling attachment needs a monitor before future routes can rely on it. The uncovered afterlife is monitor substitution: a later desk can move the monitor, replace the monitor, cite an old watcher for a new attachment, or treat a captured checksum as fresh authority.

The source compliance remains true. This storyline asks whether the later monitor change is scoped, receipted, and consumed by future play instead of becoming clean invisible paperwork.

Playable question

When an attachment monitor is replaced or reused, does production retain the original monitor, authorize a substitute, split monitor scope, publish the substitution, quarantine the monitor chain, convert the substitution into monitor debt, refuse the swap with a scar, or let a false monitor substitution become the default?

Every answer must name:

• the source ruling or attachment row;
• the original monitor;
• the replacement monitor or explicit absence;
• the authority scope or explicit absence;
• the substitution reason;
• the harmed or omitted reader;
• the selected monitor posture;
• the monitor state after;
• the future reader or route effect.

State-triggered entry

Open this storyline only when a future reader is about to consume a changed monitor state:

entry_state:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  source_attachment_row_visible: true
  original_monitor_visible: true
  replacement_monitor_or_absence_visible: true
  monitor_authority_scope_visible: true
  substitution_reason_visible: true
  harmed_or_omitted_reader_visible: true
  future_reader_or_route_consumes_monitor_state: true
  player_can_retain_authorize_split_publish_quarantine_convert_refuse_or_default: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
  no_fixed_day_or_week_trigger: true
  no_raw_monitor_count_trigger: true
  no_dashboard_or_lens_health_trigger: true

Do not open this storyline from a turn number, cleanup timer, raw monitor count, dashboard status, lens health, or generic compliance backlog.

Bound content pack

• Attachment Monitor Substitution Receipt defines monitor states, valid substitutions, branch families, and false-clean default.
• Attachment Monitor Substitution Docket records the source row, original monitor, replacement monitor, scope, reason, harmed reader, after-state, and future effect.
• Attachment Monitor Substitution Hearing resolves retain, authorize, split, publish, quarantine, convert, refuse, or default branches.
• False Monitor Substitution Default records a false-clean monitor swap and its future scar.
• Attachment Monitor Substitution Receipt Lens observes the packet contract.

Storyline spine

Beat 1 - A valid monitor is no longer obviously current

A ruling attachment, capacity notice, archive enforcement row, service recipient row, or route asset protection state already has monitor proof. Later state pressure changes that proof: the monitor is reassigned, captured, stale, bought, contradicted, unavailable, or asked to cover a second attachment.

Beat 2 - The docket separates monitor from authority

Create or refresh Attachment Monitor Substitution Docket.

attachment_monitor_substitution_docket:
  source_ruling_or_attachment_row: storyteller.card.ruling_attachment_ledger.v1 | <equivalent>
  source_attachment_row:
    row_id: <row>
    attachment_kind: monitor | proof_bridge | route_asset_protection | channel_limit | equivalent
  original_monitor:
    monitor_id: <monitor card character checksum witness or seal>
    monitor_state_before: assigned | served | public_only | lawful_only | sponsor_gated | contested | captured | stale | explicit_absence
  replacement_monitor_or_absence:
    monitor_id: <replacement or explicit_absence>
    qualification_state: qualified | narrower_scope | public_only | lawful_only | sponsor_only | captured | stale | unqualified | explicit_absence
  authority_scope_or_absence:
    scope: same_attachment | narrowed_reader | split_reader | temporary_substitute | emergency_only | no_transfer | explicit_absence
  substitution_reason:
    reason: monitor_unavailable | monitor_captured | scope_changed | route_asset_moved | lawful_channel_changed | public_receipt_challenge | sponsor_pressure | equivalent
  harmed_or_omitted_reader:
    reader: inspector | archive | sponsor | editor | public_fan | artist | witness | manager | route_asset | explicit_absence
  selected_monitor_posture: retain_original_monitor | authorize_replacement_monitor | split_monitor_scope | publish_monitor_substitution | quarantine_monitor_chain | convert_to_monitor_debt | refuse_substitution_with_scar | false_monitor_substitution_default
  monitor_state_after: retained | substituted_scoped | split_required | public_notice_required | quarantined | monitor_debt | refused_with_scar | false_clean_substitute | recovery_only
  future_reader_or_route_effect: accepted_with_original | accepted_with_substitute_cost | split_required | public_recheck_required | bridge_required | blocked | costlier | recovery_only

The docket fails if it stores only monitor changed, watcher assigned, seal accepted, or checksum replaced without original monitor, replacement authority, harmed reader, after-state, and future effect.

Beat 3 - The hearing chooses a monitor posture

Run Attachment Monitor Substitution Hearing before the future route consumes the changed monitor.

Valid branch families:

Branch	Relief	Cost	Future effect
retain_original_monitor	Original monitor remains authoritative.	Replacement desk waits or pays handler burden.	accepted_with_original
authorize_replacement_monitor	Qualified substitute carries one attachment.	Scope narrows and proof bridge cost rises.	accepted_with_substitute_cost
split_monitor_scope	Original and replacement each cover named readers.	Every reader inherits a narrower monitor scar.	split_required
publish_monitor_substitution	Public notice blocks hidden monitor swaps.	Public challenge and inspection heat rise.	public_recheck_required
quarantine_monitor_chain	False monitor authority is blocked.	Route delays until bridge proof exists.	bridge_required
convert_to_monitor_debt	Current use proceeds with named monitor debt.	Future route becomes costlier.	costlier
refuse_substitution_with_scar	Unsafe swap is rejected.	Current route blocks or turns recovery-only.	blocked or recovery_only
false_monitor_substitution_default	No one scopes the swap before use.	Hidden monitor capture becomes default.	recovery_only

Beat 4 - Future readers consume monitor state

The line is complete only when a future reader consumes monitor_state_after instead of the raw monitor name. Examples:

• Ruling Attachment Compliance accepts a substitute only with the named cost.
• Enforcement Mandate Exhaustion treats a borrowed monitor as mandate pressure.
• Archive Enforcement Docket can reject a sponsor-gated replacement.
• Service Recipient Authority Drift can demand public recheck when the recipient also became monitor.
• Route Asset Maintenance Triage can mark a monitored asset costlier or recovery-only.

Default

If a later reader consumes the substitute as clean authority, arm False Monitor Substitution Default.

false_monitor_substitution_default:
  false_clean_monitor_claim: true
  source_attachment_row: <row>
  replaced_monitor: <original monitor>
  hidden_or_unqualified_monitor: <replacement monitor or explicit_absence>
  harmed_or_omitted_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
  monitor_state_after: false_clean_substitute | captured_monitor | stale_monitor | sponsor_only_monitor | recovery_only
  future_reader_effect: blocked | costlier | public_recheck_required | bridge_required | recovery_only
  counter_deltas_min: 3
  durable_mutation: true

Non-goals

• Not a new verdict or a new compliance hearing.
• Not a generic personnel reassignment.
• Not a raw monitor-capacity counter.
• Not valid if the replacement monitor unlocks every future reader cleanly.