Callback Consumption Proof Lens / 回叫消费证明 Lens

This lens observes whether 回叫消费证明线 and 回叫消费证明机制 correctly make downstream readers consume callback state before accepting prior relief as proof, closure, precedent, slot authority, sponsor release, route unlock, public receipt, lawful annex, ending scar, or broadcast fact.

The existing mesh is already strong at creating relief callbacks. The gap this lens targets is later citation: a future route can still become false-clean if it sees only the relief and forgets who was owed the callback. A passing implementation proves that callback-bearing relief cannot be reused cleanly unless the source row, callback state, owed reader, excluded/deferred reader, carrier/proof bridge, selected posture, cost, and future reader effect are visible.

Primary observation link

This lens observes:

• 回叫消费证明线;
• 回叫消费证明机制;
• 回叫消费案卷;
• 回叫消费复核;
• 回叫洗白默认;
• 救济回叫义务线 and 救济回叫义务机制;
• downstream consumer lines such as 播出档期合约绑定线, 播出署名反诉线, and 呼吸追缴扣押线.

It is observed through:

• 回叫消费案卷;
• 回叫消费复核;
• 回叫洗白默认.

Observable promise

Relief cannot become clean closure merely because it is cited by a future reader.

When a future reader consumes a relief row, the implementation must prove:

• which relief row exists;
• which surface created it;
• who benefited from relief;
• what callback state travels with it or why absence is explicit;
• which delayed obligation exists;
• who is owed the callback;
• who was excluded, deferred, burdened, or explicitly absent;
• who now wants to use the relief;
• what the intended use is;
• who carries the callback or why carrier is explicitly absent;
• what proof bridge exists or why proof is explicitly absent;
• how the reader scope is bounded;
• what cost, scar, quarantine, waiver harm, or default follows;
• how the future reader changes state.

The lens fails if the output is only relief accepted, package closed, slot authorized, sponsor released, public forgave, lawful annex complete, route unlocked, or ending eligible.

Entry oracle

A valid implementation opens only from live downstream-consumption pressure:

entry_state_required:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  source_relief_row_present: true
  relief_has_callback_state_or_explicit_absence: true
  downstream_reader_requests_consumption: true
  future_reader_present: true
  intended_use_present: true
  owed_reader_or_explicit_absence_present: true
  excluded_or_deferred_reader_or_explicit_absence_present: true
  player_can_accept_scope_attach_publish_quarantine_waive_or_default: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
  no_fixed_day_or_week_trigger: true
  no_raw_relief_count_trigger: true
  no_dashboard_or_lens_health_trigger: true

The lens must fail if entry comes from fixed turn count, day/week interval, chapter quota, raw relief count, dashboard state, lens health, generic aftermath, generic legal review, or a clean report phase without both a source relief row and a downstream consumption attempt.

Docket oracle

回叫消费案卷 or equivalent must record:

docket_required:
  source_relief:
    source_relief_id: <stable id or explicit_absence>
    source_surface: oxygen_clawback | broadcast_slot | signatory_counterclaim | relief_callback | future_broadcast | sponsor_release | public_receipt | lawful_annex | route_asset | equivalent
    relief_beneficiary: sponsor | public | lawful_reader | archive | artist | fan_public | route_asset | management | producer_license | equivalent
    relief_granted: stay | release | haircut | correction | variance | public_receipt | lawful_conversion | slot_authority | route_unlock | equivalent
  callback_memory:
    callback_state_before: honored | assigned | owed | deferred | disputed | converted | quarantined | waived_with_named_harm | defaulted | explicit_absence
    delayed_obligation: notice | repayment | service | correction | recourse | public_answer | lawful_annex | witness_protection | route_asset_return | equivalent
    owed_to_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
    excluded_or_deferred_reader: <reader or explicit_absence>
    callback_carrier_or_absence: producer | shen_luo | yu_lan | han_yanshuang | baiya | archive_clerk | sponsor_counsel | witness | public_delegate | explicit_absence | equivalent
  future_consumption:
    future_reader: public | lawful_reader | archive | sponsor | management | route_asset | broadcast_reality | producer_license | black_box_reader | equivalent
    intended_use: proof_package | closure_report | precedent_citation | slot_binding | sponsor_release | route_unlock | public_receipt | lawful_annex | ending_scar | equivalent
    proof_bridge_or_absence: receipt | archive_stamp | lawful_annex | public_bulletin | edit_checksum | witness_receipt | sponsor_unwind | route_asset_release | explicit_absence | equivalent
    selected_posture: accept_with_callback | attach_callback_cost | convert_reader_scope | publish_callback_debt | quarantine_relief | waive_with_named_harm | launder_as_clean_default
    future_reader_effect: accepted_with_callback | costlier | callback_required | public_only | lawful_only | sponsor_only | split_required | contradiction_pending | blocked | hostile | recovery_only | false_clean_relief

The lens fails if the docket lacks source relief, callback state, owed reader, excluded/deferred reader, future reader, intended use, selected posture, or future reader effect.

Review oracle

回叫消费复核 or equivalent must require explicit assignments:

assignment_required:
  docket: storyteller.card.callback_consumption_docket.v1
  source_relief_row: <row id or explicit_absence>
  callback_state: <state or explicit_absence>
  owed_reader_or_absence: <reader or explicit_absence>
  excluded_or_deferred_reader_or_absence: <reader or explicit_absence>
  future_reader: <reader>
  intended_use: <use>
  carrier_or_absence: <handler or explicit_absence>
  proof_bridge_or_absence: <proof bridge or explicit_absence>
  selected_posture: accept_with_callback | attach_callback_cost | convert_reader_scope | publish_callback_debt | quarantine_relief | waive_with_named_harm | launder_as_clean_default
  boundary_cost_or_absence: <cost scar or explicit_absence>
  future_reader_effect: <effect>

The lens fails if sponsor payment, public sympathy, lawful language, archive stamp, edit checksum, management urgency, or broadcast reality can erase the callback without these assignments.

Branch divergence oracle

A satisfying implementation must prove at least five non-equivalent branch families plus default or quarantine.

Branch family	Required relief	Required cost	Required future effect
Accept with callback	future reader accepts relief with callback visible	route delay, handler burden, complexity	accepted_with_callback or costlier
Attach callback cost	route proceeds while callback remains carried	callback debt, owed reader leverage	callback_required or costlier
Convert reader scope	relief usable only by named surface	incompatible reader pressure	public_only, lawful_only, sponsor_only, split_required
Publish callback debt	hidden callback becomes public/lawful/archive memory	sponsor pressure, public confusion, lawful heat	contradiction_pending or annex required
Quarantine relief	clean consumption blocked	route delay, archive debt, recovery pressure	blocked or recovery_only
Waive with named harm	narrow fast route allowed	harmed reader hostility and future recovery cost	hostile or contradiction_pending
Launder as clean default	immediate pressure may drop	false-clean relief hardens	false_clean_relief, blocked, hostile, recovery_only

No branch may produce clean acceptance across public, lawful, sponsor, archive, route asset, management, producer-license, and broadcast-reality readers.

Laundering default oracle

回叫洗白默认 or equivalent must fire or be armed when:

• future reader consumes relief without consumption docket;
• source relief row is hidden;
• callback state is missing or hidden;
• owed reader is hidden;
• excluded or deferred reader is hidden;
• carrier is missing without explicit absence;
• proof bridge is missing without explicit absence;
• waiver proceeds without named harm;
• relief is packaged, cited, closed, aired, or routed as clean.

Required default payload:

default_required:
  event: storyteller.event.callback_laundering_default.v1
  source_relief:
    source_relief_id: <stable id or explicit_absence>
    source_surface: <surface or explicit_absence>
    relief_beneficiary: <reader or explicit_absence>
    relief_granted: <relief or explicit_absence>
  missing_callback:
    callback_state_missing_or_hidden: true | false
    delayed_obligation_missing_or_hidden: true | false
    owed_to_reader_missing_or_hidden: true | false
    excluded_or_deferred_reader_missing_or_hidden: true | false
    callback_carrier_missing_or_hidden: true | false
    proof_bridge_missing_or_hidden: true | false
    waiver_harm_missing_or_hidden: true | false
  clean_claim: <claim>
  default_narrator: owed_reader | excluded_reader | sponsor | archive | lawful_reader | public_table | route_asset | broadcast_reality | blackout_system | management | equivalent
  future_reader_effect: false_clean_relief | blocked | hostile | contradiction_pending | public_only | lawful_only | sponsor_only | split_required | recovery_only | equivalent

The lens fails if default produces a clean reset or generic bad state without naming clean claim, narrator, and future effect.

Downstream consumer oracle

The content is not complete until at least one later reader consumes the callback state. Valid consumers include:

• 播出档期合约绑定线 consuming relief before accepting a slot;
• 播出署名反诉线 consuming relief before accepting a release;
• 呼吸追缴扣押线 consuming relief before accepting stay, haircut, or foreclosure closure;
• 林夕未来广播见证线 consuming relief before accepting future-signal proof;
• equivalent public, lawful, sponsor, archive, route asset, management, producer-license, broadcast-reality, or ending reader.

Passing effects include:

• accepted_with_callback;
• callback_required;
• costlier;
• public_only;
• lawful_only;
• sponsor_only;
• split_required;
• contradiction_pending;
• blocked;
• hostile;
• recovery_only;
• false_clean_relief.

Oracle assertions

A check should fail unless all assertions below are true.

1. Primary links exist — the lens has populated observes and observed_through arrays pointing to concrete pages.
2. State entry is non-sequential — the surface opens from downstream consumption of callback-bearing relief, not fixed count, interval, chapter quota, dashboard, or lens health.
3. Source relief is visible — source row, surface, beneficiary, and relief granted are available or explicitly absent with cost.
4. Callback memory is visible — callback state, delayed obligation, owed reader, excluded/deferred reader, and carrier/absence are recorded.
5. Future reader is named — the consumer and intended use are explicit before resolution.
6. Review is assignable — the rite requires source relief, callback state, future reader, carrier/proof bridge, selected posture, and boundary cost or absence.
7. Reader scope matters — public, lawful, sponsor, archive, route asset, management, producer-license, and broadcast-reality readers cannot all accept the same relief as clean proof.
8. Every success has cost — any branch that unlocks, accepts, legitimizes, or releases relief must worsen another surface or attach a scar.
9. Quarantine is not consumption — quarantined relief is preserved but cannot be cited as clean proof.
10. Laundering is durable — missing callback state must create a default narrator and mutate future route, reader state, counters, tags, or ending scar.
11. Downstream consumption exists — passing evidence includes a later consumer reading the result.
12. Replay provenance exists — evidence includes session id, seed, source row, offered choices, assignments, branch outcomes, event/default state, and counter deltas; provenance is not trigger logic.

Progress metric

callbackConsumptionProofProgress = 0..8:

• 0: no downstream consumption attempt or no provenance.
• 1: source relief row and future reader are present.
• 2: intended use and callback state are visible.
• 3: owed reader and excluded/deferred reader or explicit absence are visible.
• 4: 回叫消费案卷 or equivalent enters play.
• 5: 回叫消费复核 or equivalent offers assignable slots.
• 6: at least four branch choices are visible and gated by callback state, reader scope, carrier, proof bridge, or explicit absence.
• 7: at least two successful branches produce distinct counter deltas and future-reader effects.
• 8: at least five branch families are proven with replay/session evidence, including one quarantine or 回叫洗白默认 branch and one downstream consumer route.

Evidence shape

lens_id: storyteller.lens.callback_consumption_proof.v1
session_id: lens-callback-consumption-proof-v1-<timestamp>
seed: <deterministic-seed>
entry_state:
  trigger_kind: state_pressure
  source_relief_row_present: true
  relief_has_callback_state_or_explicit_absence: true
  downstream_reader_requests_consumption: true
  future_reader_present: true
  intended_use_present: true
  owed_reader_or_explicit_absence_present: true
  excluded_or_deferred_reader_or_explicit_absence_present: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
source_relief:
  source_relief_id: <stable id>
  source_surface: <surface>
  relief_beneficiary: <reader>
  relief_granted: <relief>
callback_memory:
  callback_state_before: <state>
  delayed_obligation: <obligation>
  owed_reader_or_absence: <reader or explicit_absence>
  excluded_or_deferred_reader_or_absence: <reader or explicit_absence>
consumer:
  future_reader: <reader>
  intended_use: <use>
active_objects:
  docket: storyteller.card.callback_consumption_docket.v1
  rite: storyteller.rite.callback_consumption_review.v1
offered_choices:
  - accept_with_callback
  - attach_callback_cost
  - convert_reader_scope
  - publish_callback_debt
  - quarantine_relief
  - waive_with_named_harm
  - launder_as_clean_default
branch_runs:
  accept_with_callback:
    callback_consumption_state_after: accepted_with_callback
    counter_deltas:
      callback_legitimacy: +1
      route_delay: +1
    future_reader_effect: accepted_with_callback | costlier
  attach_callback_cost:
    callback_consumption_state_after: cost_attached
    counter_deltas:
      callback_debt: +1
      future_route_cost: +1
    future_reader_effect: callback_required | costlier
  convert_reader_scope:
    callback_consumption_state_after: reader_scoped
    counter_deltas:
      false_clean_relief: -1
      incompatible_reader_pressure: +1
    future_reader_effect: public_only | lawful_only | sponsor_only | split_required
  publish_callback_debt:
    callback_consumption_state_after: debt_published
    counter_deltas:
      callback_discoverability: +1
      lawful_heat: +1
    future_reader_effect: contradiction_pending | annex_required
  quarantine_relief:
    callback_consumption_state_after: quarantined
    counter_deltas:
      false_clean_relief: -1
      route_delay: +1
    future_reader_effect: blocked | recovery_only | contradiction_pending
  waive_with_named_harm:
    callback_consumption_state_after: waived_with_named_harm
    counter_deltas:
      owed_reader_hostility: +1
      future_recovery_cost: +1
    future_reader_effect: hostile | costlier | contradiction_pending
  laundering_default:
    event_seen_or_armed: storyteller.event.callback_laundering_default.v1
    default_narrator: <actor>
    counter_deltas:
      false_clean_relief: +1
      callback_laundering: +1
    future_reader_effect: false_clean_relief | blocked | hostile | recovery_only
downstream_consumer:
  consumer_surface: broadcast_slot | signatory_counterclaim | oxygen_clawback | future_broadcast_witness | public_receipt | lawful_annex | sponsor_release | archive_copy | route_asset | ending_scar | equivalent
  consumed_state: <state>
  route_or_reader_effect_after: <effect>
assertions:
  - entry_is_state_triggered_from_downstream_consumption
  - relief_cannot_be_consumed_cleanly_without_callback_state
  - future_reader_named
  - branch_outcomes_diverge
  - laundering_default_is_durable
  - downstream_reader_consumes_callback_state
  - no_fixed_turn_day_week_raw_count_dashboard_or_lens_health_trigger

Non-goals

• Not the original relief-callback lens.
• Not a generic evidence or legal review lens.
• Not a QA governance page.
• Not a dashboard/lens-health response.
• Not a raw-count expansion.
• Not valid if relief can be consumed as clean proof by a future reader without callback memory and cost.