Ning Zhe Desk Liaison Counteroffer Lens / 宁折桌间反报价联络 Lens

Primary observation link

This lens observes Desk Liaison Counteroffer Broker, 宁折桌间反报价联络线, 桌间联络人反报价机制, 播出实在漂移审计, 代理人姿态链, 反向同盟锁线, and Route Assets and Custody.

It is observed through 桌间联络人反报价案卷, 桌间联络人反报价听证, 联络人倒戈反报价, 实在漂移案卷, and 实在漂移审计.

Observable promise

Storyteller must prove that cross-desk counteroffers are carried by a concrete person-state surface, not hidden desk mood.

When a producer has already selected or started to select a sponsor, inspector, archive, editor, public, or management solution, and a second desk tries to rewrite those terms, the implementation must expose:

• source surface;
• first desk terms;
• second desk counteroffer terms or explicit absence;
• liaison state;
• assignment slots;
• selected response;
• branch deltas;
• future route effect.

The lens fails if the player can shop one contradiction across desks and receive clean universal closure.

Runtime certification route

The broad six-branch hearing remains an authored compatibility surface. It does not require the new Ning Zhe packet’s positive flags or exact cards; only reciprocal negative terminal guards prevent it from stacking with the strict review. Runtime certification uses one narrower, source-backed character route so legacy option indices and unrelated durable replays remain valid.

The oracle requires:

• the source replay assigns starter-backed slot.last_air_edit, asset.lyra_voiceprint, sponsor.haloair, and card.voice_rights_token from hand to rite.reality_drift_audit;
• only appended choice 6, rite.reality_drift_audit:file_liaison_counteroffer_docket, gains actual Ning Zhe and the non-starter counteroffer docket; established choices 0–5 retain their prior results;
• rite.storyteller.ning_zhe_desk_liaison_disposition_review.v1 requires five exact in-hand cards and an explicit selected option;
• recruitment retains Ning Zhe, creates exactly one bounded route asset, and never creates the miss receipt;
• default first arms the high-priority defection event, then removes Ning Zhe, retains exactly one counterreceipt, and creates no route asset;
• exactly one runtime route flag and one terminal Ning Zhe state remain after either route;
• both focused Game CLI replays come from source: storyteller and use the normal starter-backed source entry.

Scope

This lens covers:

• counteroffers after drift audit, custody receipt, sponsor settlement, inspector docket, editorial patch, public receipt, quarantine, route asset settlement, or legality conversion;
• 宁折 as a concrete carrier, broker, witness, recruitable route asset, or visibly missed hostile liaison;
• legacy accept, protect, expose, suppress/trade, defer, and default vocabulary, plus executable recruit and hostile-missing-recovery-only terminal routes;
• counter/state changes that include both relief and cost;
• future route, proof, public receipt, desk posture, route asset, or broadcast reality mutation.

It does not cover generic negotiation, faction reputation, or abstract legal review.

Entry oracle

A valid replay or game-state inspection must open this surface from state, not fixed chronology.

entry_required:
  source_surface_present: true
  source_surface_kind: reality_drift_docket | custody_receipt | sponsor_settlement | inspector_audit | editorial_patch | public_receipt | route_asset_settlement | legality_conversion | equivalent
  first_desk_terms_visible: true
  counteroffer_terms_visible_or_explicit_absence: true
  desks_min: 2
  liaison_state_visible_or_explicit_absence: true
  future_route_effect_possible: true
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
  no_fixed_day_trigger: true
  no_dashboard_or_lens_health_trigger: true
  no_raw_count_trigger: true

The lens fails if entry comes from generic faction anger, generic difficulty, time passage, dashboard state, lens health, or a counteroffer with no concrete carrier.

Docket oracle

桌间联络人反报价案卷 or equivalent must record:

docket_required:
  source_surface: <source surface id>
  previous_selected_desk: <desk>
  previous_terms: <terms>
  counteroffering_desk: <desk>
  counteroffer_terms_or_absence: <terms or explicit_absence>
  liaison: storyteller.character.ning_zhe_desk_liaison.v1 | equivalent | explicit_missing_liaison
  liaison_state_before: unseen | offered | retained | recruited | exposed | suppressed | faction_bound | hostile | missed | equivalent
  handler_or_absence: <handler or explicit_absence>
  proof_or_absence: <proof or explicit_absence>
  protection_or_price_or_absence: <support/cost or explicit_absence>
  selected_response: accept_counteroffer | reject_and_protect_first_terms | expose_counteroffer | suppress_liaison | trade_liaison | defer_with_debt | miss_or_default
  state_after: <durable state>
  counter_deltas: <relief and cost>
  future_route_effect: <effect>

The lens fails if the docket records only desk names, legal warning text, or mood pressure.

Assignment oracle

桌间联络人反报价听证 or equivalent must require assignment or explicit absence for:

• source docket/surface;
• first desk terms;
• counteroffer terms;
• liaison;
• handler;
• proof;
• protection, price, or support;
• selected response;
• accepted cost surface;
• future route effect.

A famous handler, sponsor money, lawful phrase, editor patch, or public sympathy cannot satisfy the lens unless the liaison and quote fields remain visible.

Branch divergence oracle

A satisfying implementation must prove at least five non-equivalent branch families. The default/failure family is mandatory.

Branch A — Accept counteroffer

Expected evidence:

• second desk terms become selected, accepted, or provisionally carried;
• one second-desk pressure, route gate, proof bridge, or immediate cost improves;
• first-desk hostility, public distrust, inspection heat, contract capture, archive debt, edit debt, or source ambiguity rises;
• future route effect names reopened first terms, faction gate, or follow-up hearing.

Branch B — Reject and protect first terms

Expected evidence:

• original solution remains usable;
• counteroffering desk becomes hostile, watchful, subordinated, deferred, or blackmail-capable;
• liaison exposure, future blackmail, coalition pressure, or claimant hostility rises.

Branch C — Expose counteroffer

Expected evidence:

• public receipt, lawful filing, fan witness, historian proof, or source proof uses the quote;
• public receipt legitimacy, false-owner pressure, or private-capture resistance improves;
• sponsor pressure, inspection heat, liaison exposure, witness retaliation, pirate exposure, or fan oxygen risk rises;
• future protection, payroll, appeal, or shelter is required.

Branch D — Suppress or trade liaison

Expected evidence:

• liaison is hidden, edited out, frozen, intimidated, sold, faction-bound, or cut out;
• immediate contradiction or desk noise improves;
• public receipt distrust, edit debt, archive debt, route capture, source ambiguity, or hostile leak risk rises;
• clean recruitment is blocked or future use becomes faction-gated.

Branch E — Defer with debt

Expected evidence:

• decision pressure drops or stays manageable;
• both desk claims remain visible;
• future blackmail, handler burden, counteroffer pressure, or route asset pressure rises;
• later hearing is forced and no clean universal closure is recorded.

Branch F — Miss or default

Expected evidence:

• missing handler/proof/support/liaison/response is recorded;
• 联络人倒戈反报价 fires or arms;
• liaison becomes the executable composite hostile_missing_recovery_only state;
• at least one future route, proof, public receipt, desk posture, route asset, or broadcast reality state becomes blocked, costlier, public-only, lawful-only, sponsor-gated, editor-gated, or recovery-only.

Required durable states

At least eight equivalent states must be visible across content or replay evidence:

• counteroffer_open
• liaison_retained_one_quote
• liaison_recruited_counteroffer_broker
• first_terms_protected
• counteroffer_accepted_with_scar
• counteroffer_exposed_publicly
• liaison_suppressed_or_traded
• counteroffer_deferred_with_debt
• counteroffer_defaulted
• hostile_liaison
• missing_liaison
• recovery_only_liaison

Counter oracle

Every non-default branch must show at least three counter/state deltas with both relief and cost. A default branch must show durable penalty.

Accepted surfaces include:

• desk_counteroffer_pressure
• liaison_trust
• liaison_exposure
• liaison_capture_risk
• route_asset_pressure
• reality_drift
• public_receipt_legitimacy
• public_receipt_distrust
• sponsor_stop_loss_pressure
• contract_capture
• inspection_heat
• bureau_favor_debt
• archive_debt
• edit_debt
• source_ambiguity
• fan_oxygen_resentment
• payroll_leak
• handler_burden
• claimant_hostility
• future_blackmail_cost
• future_recovery_cost

The lens fails if success removes all desk pressure, if a counteroffer has no future scar, or if hostile/missed liaison state is only prose.

Progress metric

ningZheDeskLiaisonCounterofferProgress = 0..10:

• 0: no source surface with first desk terms.
• 1: source surface and first desk terms are visible.
• 2: second desk counteroffer terms or explicit absence are visible.
• 3: 宁折 or equivalent liaison state is visible or explicitly absent.
• 4: docket records source surface, desks, terms, liaison, handler/proof/support, selected response, and future effect.
• 5: hearing offers assignable branches with handler, proof, protection/price, and explicit absence handling.
• 6: at least three branch families are visible.
• 7: at least two non-default branches produce distinct relief/cost deltas.
• 8: default produces the visible hostile-missing-recovery-only liaison state and changes future play.
• 9: recruited or retained liaison remains usable or costlier in a later route.
• 10: replay/session evidence proves first desk terms, second desk terms, liaison assignment, branch divergence, future effect, and no clean universal closure.

Evidence shape

lens_id: storyteller.lens.character.ning_zhe_desk_liaison_counteroffer.v1
session_id: lens-ning-zhe-desk-liaison-counteroffer-v1-<timestamp>
seed: <deterministic-seed>
state_context:
  source_surface_kind: reality_drift_docket | custody_receipt | sponsor_settlement | inspector_audit | editorial_patch | public_receipt | route_asset_settlement | legality_conversion | equivalent
  source_surface_id: <id>
  first_desk: sponsor | inspector | archive | editor | public_fan | management | lawful_reader | equivalent
  first_terms: <terms>
  selected_or_pending_state: <state>
  second_desk: <desk>
  counteroffer_terms_or_absence: <terms or explicit_absence>
  no_fixed_turn_trigger: true
liaison_context:
  liaison: storyteller.character.ning_zhe_desk_liaison.v1 | equivalent | explicit_missing_liaison
  liaison_state_before: unseen | offered | retained | recruited | exposed | suppressed | faction_bound | hostile | missed | equivalent
  route_asset_state_before: none | route_asset.ning_zhe_counteroffer_broker | hostile | missing | recovery_only | equivalent
assignment:
  docket: storyteller.card.desk_liaison_counteroffer_docket.v1
  rite: storyteller.rite.desk_liaison_counteroffer_hearing.v1
  handler_or_absence: <handler or explicit_absence>
  proof_or_absence: <proof or explicit_absence>
  protection_or_price_or_absence: <support or explicit_absence>
  selected_response: accept_counteroffer | reject_and_protect_first_terms | expose_counteroffer | suppress_liaison | trade_liaison | defer_with_debt | miss_or_default
branch_result:
  state_after: <state>
  liaison_state_after: <state>
  emitted_event: storyteller.event.liaison_defection_counteroffer.v1 | none
  counter_deltas:
    relief: []
    cost: []
  future_route_effect: <effect>
assertions:
  - primary_links_exist
  - entry_is_state_triggered
  - first_and_second_desk_terms_visible
  - liaison_state_visible_or_explicitly_absent
  - docket_memory_exists
  - assignment_slots_exist
  - branch_outcomes_diverge
  - success_has_cost
  - default_or_hostile_liaison_is_durable
  - future_route_effect_mutates
  - no_clean_universal_closure_across_desks

Non-goals

• Not raw lens-count increase.
• Not filler NPC recruitment.
• Not generic diplomacy.
• Not generic legal review.
• Not a faction reputation meter.
• Not a fixed-turn escalation.
• Not valid if 宁折 becomes a free courier or a clean universal settlement key.
• Not satisfied by page existence alone; proof must come from state, assignments, branch divergence, deltas, and future route effects.